abstractmath.org

help with abstract math

Produced by Charles Wells.  Home.   Website Contents     Website Index   
Back to top of Understanding Math chapter

Posted 7 May 2009

REPRESENTATIONS AND MODELS

 

A representation of a math object can be one of the several types:

¨  Mental representation. 

¨  Mathematical representation.

¨  Model.

¨  Physical representation.

These types are fuzzy and overlap.  You can argue about whether some examples are of one type or another.  The word “representation” is not used for all of them and many mathematicians would not use the word in as general a sense as I use it here.  This section discusses representations, except that mental representations are discussed mostly in the chapter Images and metaphors.

Contents

Representations. 1

Examples. 1

What are representations good for?. 3

Mathematical and informal representations. 3

Models. 4

Model as mathematical object 4

Physical models. 4

Representations

Examples

Representations of integers

An integer can be represented in decimal notation, binary notation, hexadecimal notation and in prime factorization notation:

 

Decimal

Binary

Hexadecimal

Prime Fac.

199

11000111

C7

199

200

11001000

C8

 

201

11001001

C9

 

202

11001010

CA

 

203

11001011

CB

 

204

11001100

CC

 

205

11001101

CD

 

206

11001110

CE

 

207

11001111

CF

 

208

11010000

D0

 

2,747,072,786

10100011101111010000000100010010

A3BD0112

 

 

The decimal representation of an integer may be more familiar to you than one of the other representations given above, but it is not the only genuine or legal one  it is only more familiar and (perhaps) more useful. 

 

When you see the expression “  ” you know what the integer is. 

You may crave to know the decimal representation

 because the integer does not somehow seem real to you until you know it,

but that is a human feeling not based on a mathematical property of integers.

Note

The decimal representation “207” is a mathematical representation, but when you think about the number 207 you may in fact visualize the sequence “207” of digits, so the decimal representation, at least up to (perhaps) seven digits, can also correspond to a mental representation in the form of notation.  More about this here.

Functions

¨  A function may be given by a formula. 

¨  A continuous function on the real numbers has a graph. The graph of a function is a mathematical object, but the drawing you may make of the graph (like the picture to the left) is a physical representation.

¨  A finite function may be given by a table of values. 

¨  A linear transformation on a finite dimensional vector space can be represented by a matrix.

The chapter on images and metaphors for functions describes many ways to think about functions, including the first three above.   

Rectangles

The picture to the right represents the rectangle with sides 2, 3, 2, 3 .   You might draw a picture of it on a chalkboard that would look like this picture.  These are physical representations of the rectangle.  When you think about it you may visualize a very similar picture.

You may represent this rectangle in the real plane by giving coordinates of its corners, for example (0, 0), (0, 2), (3, 0), (3, 2).  Of course, the corners (0, 1), (0, 3), (3, 1), (3, 3) gives another representation in the plane of the same rectangle.

The family of rectangles of different sizes may given by parameters, two real numbers representing the lengths of two adjacent sides.   (If you give the length of two adjacent sides, the other two sides are determined by the fact that it is a rectangle.)  The rectangle with sides 2, 3, 2, 3  then has parameters (2, 3).  This is a representation of the rectangle that, for example, allows you to calculate the area easily.

Rectangles and their parametrization and representation will eventually be discussed in the chapters on parameters and on isomorphism and identity.

 

What are representations good for?

A representation of a math object helps in many ways.

The representation may identify the object.

The decimal notation ‘2,747,072,786’  and the prime factor representation  identify the same positive integer.  Both identify it completely; there is no doubt about which integer it is.  Representations that identify the object are commonly used as symbolic names of the object.  See structural notation.

Other representations do not completely identify the object. 

¨  A sketch of the graph of a function defined on the reals does not determine the function completely because it can’t be perfectly accurate and it can’t show all the values.

¨  A picture of a rectangle is also not prefectly accurate, so does not completely identify it.

The representation may enable you to deduce some properties of the object.

¨  The decimal notation ‘2,747,072,786’ gives you a good idea of the size of that integer.  You can tell at a glance that it is between two and three billion.  It is more difficult to use that representation to determine the prime factors. 

¨  The prime factor representation  of the same number makes it immediately obvious what its prime factors are but does not make it easy to tell how big it is.

¨  If you know about how integers are represented in computers, you can tell at a glance from the hexadecimal notation A3BD0112 that it is too big to be represented as a “long” integer (on 32 bit machines).  That is because it uses eight hex digits and the leftmost digit is bigger than 7. 

The representation may enable you to calculate something about a math object. 

¨  You can calculate  easily because the numbers are represented in decimal notation, for which there is an easy algorithm for addition that you learned in elementary school.  Using the prime factor representation

 

or the Roman Numeral Representation

MCCCVIII + CCCLXXV = MDCLXXXIII

it is much harder to add them up because there is no efficient algorithm for computing sums using those representations.

¨  The prime factor representation makes it easy to calculate the prime factorization representation of the product of the two numbers: .   

Mathematical and informal representations

Some representations have a mathematical definition and others have a more informal status. 

Examples

¨  The representation of a linear transformation on a finite dimensional vector space as a matrix has a strict mathematical definition.  

¨  The representation of a number in decimal notation can be defined as a mathematical object, but in practice it is treated more informally.  Is the string of symbols ‘42’ a mathematical object or a typographical object?  You can think of it either way and most math texts discussing such a number won’t be precise about its status.  Sometimes, especially in computing science or logic, it is necessary to consider it as a mathematical object.

¨  The representation of a function by its graph (as here) is clearly informal, but the phrase “graph of a function” has a technical mathematical definition (a certain set of ordered pairs) as well. 

¨  The representation of a symmetry of a square described here is a mathematical representation of the symmetry.

Models

Text Box: All models are wrong... some models are useful.  --George BoxModel as mathematical object

In one of its uses in mathematical discourse, a model, or mathematical model, of a phenomenon is a mathematical object that represents the phenomenon in some sense. The phenomenon being modeled may be physical or another mathematical object.  

¨  A moving physical object has a location at each instant.  This may be modeled by a function.   (Example).  You can then determine the velocity of the object at different times by taking the derivative of the function.

¨  A word problem in algebra or calculus texts is an invitation to find a mathematical model of the problem.  You must set it up as a mathematical expression using appropriate operations and then solve for the appropriate variable.

¨  Mathematical logic has a concept of model of a theory.   Both the theory and the models are math objects. 

¨  Computing science defines various mathematical models of the concept of algorithm, for example Turing machines.  See also my discussion of the word “algorithm”.

Remark

As the examples just discussed illustrate, a model and the thing it models may be called by the same name. Thus one refers to the velocity of an object (a physical property) and one also says

“The derivative of the velocity is the acceleration.”

Of course, the derivative is a function and the acceleration is a physical property, but that is the way we talk.  A mathematical model is a special kind of metaphor and to refer to the mathematical model as if it were the thing modeled is a normal way of using metaphors.  Indeed, in rhetoric (but not here) the word “metaphor” is typically restricted to referring to this way of using them.

Physical models

A mathematical object may also have a physical modell, which is a particular kind of external representation.  Tetrahedrons and Möbius strips are mathematical objects that you can build models of out of paper.  The drawing above of the graph of a function is also a physical model.